Why Your Insurance Company Knows You Better Than Your Therapist (And They’re Still Charging You Too Much)

My car insurance just went up $40 a month. I haven’t had an accident. Haven’t gotten a ticket. Haven’t even parallel parked badly enough to warrant divine intervention. But apparently, according to the cheerful email I received, “factors in your area have changed.”

Factors. In my area. Changed.

You know what actually changed? I turned 30, moved to a “better” neighborhood, and bought a newer car with more safety features than a NASA spacecraft. By all logical metrics, I should be paying LESS. But here we are, and Geico needs another yacht, I guess.

This got me thinking about the beautiful scam that is the modern insurance industry. And before you ask – yes, I know insurance is necessary. Yes, I understand risk pools. Yes, I’ve read my policy (well, skimmed it). But that doesn’t make the whole thing any less absurd.

The Data Collection Olympics

Here’s something fun: your insurance company probably knows more about you than you know about yourself. I’m not being dramatic. These companies are basically Facebook, Google, and the NSA had a baby, and that baby really wants to know about your driving habits.

Those “safe driver” apps they push? The ones that give you a 5% discount for letting them track your every move? Yeah, those are monitoring:

How hard you brake (apparently coming to a complete stop at a stop sign is “aggressive”)
What time you drive (driving after 10 PM? That’s a risk factor, party animal)
How fast you accelerate (sorry for trying to merge onto the highway without dying)
Your location data (oh, you went to a bar? Interesting…)
Phone usage while driving (they say they don’t, but come on)

My friend Jake installed one of these apps. First month: 15% discount! Second month: his rates went up 20%. Why? The app detected he was a “high-risk driver” because he commuted during rush hour. You know, like literally everyone with a job.

The Pre-Existing Condition Paradox

Health insurance is its own special level of hell. The entire business model is essentially:

Collect money from healthy people
Try very hard not to pay when those people get sick
Act surprised when people are angry about this

I once tried to get a mole removed. Not for medical reasons – it just looked weird. My dermatologist said, “We should biopsy this, just to be safe.”

Guess what? Now I have a “history of abnormal skin lesions” in my medical records. The mole was benign. Completely harmless. But every insurance application now asks about my “skin condition history,” and my premiums reflect my apparently dangerous epidermis.

The kicker? If I hadn’t been responsible and gotten it checked, I’d be paying less. The system literally punishes you for preventive care.

The Art of Denial (It’s Not You, It’s… Actually It’s You)

Insurance companies have turned claim denial into an art form. It’s like they have a team of people whose only job is to find creative ways to say “no.”

Real reasons insurance claims get denied:

“Act of God” (apparently God is very busy destroying property)
“Gradual damage” (your roof didn’t collapse fast enough)
“Wear and tear” (things aging is your fault)
“You didn’t read paragraph 247, subsection C” (who has time for that?)
“Mercury was in retrograde” (okay, I made this one up, but barely)

My neighbor’s house flooded. Insurance denied the claim because the water came from the ground up (not covered) instead of from the sky down (covered). The water was the same water. From the same storm. But apparently, water has to follow proper protocols to be insurable.

The AI Revolution (Or: How Robots Learned to Say No Faster)

Insurance companies are all-in on AI now, and honestly, it’s making things worse. They’ve got algorithms determining your risk score based on factors like:

Your credit score (because poor people are obviously worse drivers?)
Your job title (teachers are safe, bartenders are not, apparently)
Your ZIP code (living somewhere is now a personality trait)
Your social media activity (yes, really)
What kind of car your neighbors drive (I wish I was making this up)

The best part? When you call to complain about your rate increase, the customer service rep says, “The computer calculated your premium.” THE COMPUTER. As if SkyNet is personally vendetta against your Honda Civic.

I asked one rep if she could explain why my rate went up. She literally said, “The algorithm doesn’t provide explanations.” We’ve created a system where nobody understands how decisions are made, but we all have to live with them anyway. Cool. Cool cool cool.

The Monopoly Nobody Talks About

You know what’s wild? We legally HAVE to buy some types of insurance. Car insurance? Mandatory. Health insurance? Was mandatory, still basically is unless you enjoy bankruptcy. Homeowner’s insurance? Good luck getting a mortgage without it.

So we have an industry where:

Purchase is legally required
Prices aren’t regulated (in most states)
Companies share all your data with each other
You can’t see their algorithms
They can drop you whenever they want

This would be illegal in literally any other industry. Imagine if Netflix could charge you different prices based on your browsing history, require you by law to subscribe, and then randomly decide not to let you watch shows you’ve paid for. There would be riots.

The “Shopping Around” Myth

Everyone says “just shop around for better rates!” Like insurance companies aren’t all using the same data, bought from the same brokers, processed through similar algorithms.

I spent an entire Saturday getting quotes from different companies. The range? $147 to $153 per month. Six hours of my life for a potential savings of $6. I made $1 per hour shopping for insurance. I’ve had better hourly rates at lemonade stands.

Plus, they all wanted:

My social security number
My entire driving history
My credit card info
My firstborn child (slight exaggeration)
Permission to track my location (not an exaggeration)

By the time I was done, I’m pretty sure I’d given away enough personal information to have my identity stolen twice.

The Climate Change Plot Twist

Here’s where it gets really interesting. Climate change is absolutely wrecking insurance companies’ models. They built their entire business on historical data, and suddenly, “hundred-year floods” are happening every three years.

What’s their solution? Just… stop insuring places. Seriously.

California? Major insurers are pulling out. Florida? Good luck finding hurricane coverage. Louisiana? Might as well self-insure.

These companies made billions insuring these areas for decades, but the second things get actually risky, they bounce. It’s like a casino that only wants to operate when the house edge is 90%.

The Actual Solution (That Nobody Will Implement)

You want to know what would actually fix insurance? Make it boring. I’m talking utilities-level boring.

Standardized coverage (everyone gets the same thing)
Regulated prices (like electricity)
Public option (compete with private or die)
Transparent algorithms (show your work)
Actual consequences for bad faith denials

But that would be “socialism” or whatever, so instead we get to play Insurance Company Roulette every year and hope we don’t land on medical bankruptcy.

The Bottom Line

Look, I get it. Insurance is a necessary evil. Without it, one bad accident could ruin your entire life. But the current system is like paying protection money to the mob, except the mob has better customer service and more transparent pricing.

The worst part? We’re all stuck in this together. We can’t opt out. We can’t force change. We just get to watch our premiums go up while coverage goes down, and listen to commercials about how much insurance companies care about us.

My personal solution? I’ve accepted that insurance is just a stupidity tax on modern life. I pay it, I hate it, and I try not to think about it. When I do need to file a claim, I document everything like I’m preparing for a Supreme Court case.

And you know what? My insurance company probably predicted I’d write this article. It’s probably already factored into my risk score. Next month’s premium increase will cite “factors in your area” again.

The factors? I complained on the internet.

What’s your worst insurance story? Did you actually read your entire policy? Are you one of those mythical people who successfully fought a denial and won? Drop your horror stories in the comments – misery loves company, and insurance companies love misery.

Follow for more rants about systems we can’t escape but definitely should fix.